Failure of geometric electromagnetism in the adiabatic vector Kepler problem

The magnetic moment of a particle orbiting a straight current-carrying wire may precess rapidly enough in the wire’s magnetic field to justify an adiabatic approximation, eliminating the rapid time dependence of the magnetic moment and leaving only the particle position as a slow degree of freedom. To zeroth order in the adiabatic expansion, the orbits of the particle in the plane perpendicular to the wire are Keplerian ellipses. Higher-order postadiabatic corrections make the orbits precess, but recent analysis of this “vector Kepler problem” has shown that the effective Hamiltonian incorporating a postadiabatic scalar potential (“geometric electromagnetism”) fails to predict the precession correctly, while a heuristic alternative succeeds. In this paper we resolve the apparent failure of the postadiabatic approximation, by pointing out that the correct second-order analysis produces a third Hamiltonian, in which geometric electromagnetism is supplemented by a tensor potential. The heuristic Hamiltonian of Schmiedmayer and Scrinzi is then shown to be a canonical transformation of the correct adiabatic Hamiltonian, to second order. The transformation has the important advantage of removing a 1/r³ singularity which is an artifact of the adiabatic approximation.